Solvency II (SII) investors have, historically, shied away from investing in private equity or special situations due to the high SII capital requirements. We believe that SII is more accommodating to private equity or special situations than many investors may think. SII investors may want to consider moving some of their equity allocation to special situations.
INSURANCE INVESTORS ALLOCATE LESS TO PRIVATE EQUITY THAN OTHER, COMPARABLE, INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS
According to EIOPA, only 0.7% of insurers assets were invested in private equity (PE) funds in 2020 versus 10.2% in common equity2. This may be due to the higher SII risk capital requirement for private versus common equity3. As a comparison, European pension funds commit almost 3 times as much to PE funds4 even though their assets are less than half of the European insurance asset base5. We believe that SII insurers that follow the standard model could increase their PE exposure to 20% of their overall equity allocation without increasing their SII equity capital requirement.
Determination of the SII capital requirement for a portfolio of common (type 1) and private (type 2) equity
SII capital requirements are covered under Article 169 of the EU Delegated Regulation. Article 169 describes two types of equity. Type 1 equity is described as publicly listed equity that has been listed on an OECD exchange. Type 1 equity has, under the standard model, a capital requirement of 39%. Private equity is part of the category of Type 2 equity and is assigned a capital requirement of 49%.
The equity capital requirement for a portfolio that contains both Type 1 and Type 2 equity is defined as:
The potential diversification benefit described by Exhibit 1 for combining Type 1 and Type 2 equity enables an SII investor to invest 20% of their equity allocation into private equity without any material increase in their equity risk capital requirement.
If we consider the historical returns of a low volatility PE-like strategy, such as Bain Capital’s Global Special Situations strategy (GSS), increasing the allocation to private equity could be attractive to SII insurers for following reasons.
Comparison of returns and price volatility of Bain Capital GSS, PE funds and PME
Bain Capital’s GSS strategy, and private equity funds in general, have exhibited better performance during periods of market distress than the MSCI World. They have also exhibited lower volatility and better Sharpe ratios than public market equivalents (PME). To some extent, the lower volatility reflects a difference in how private markets value their investments relative to public markets. Conservative private asset managers, typically, take market valuations onto account but they focus on the underlying fundamentals in their holdings. For example, changes in earnings or financial leverage. This is in contrast to public markets which generally change valuations based on changes in market demand. This includes, for example, inflating PE multiples or valuing callable leveraged loans above par. The differences in the approaches to pricing are, in our opinion, a reflection of the different characteristics of the underlying securities. Most of the securities held in Bain Capital’s GSS strategies, for example, are bought with the intention of holding an asset until it can be restructured and/or value-enhanced. This is a process that can take several years to execute. PMEs are made up of trading assets where supply and demand fluctates by the minute. In our opinion, the alignment between PE-style offerings and the long-term investment intentions of insurance clients is reflected in the lower volatility of returns.
Please consider the following:
In this material Bain Capital Credit, LP, Bain Capital Credit (Australia), Pty. Ltd., Bain Capital Credit, Ltd., Bain Capital Investments (Europe) Limited, Bain Capital Investments (Ireland) Limited, Bain Capital Credit CLO Advisors, LP, Bain Capital Credit U.S. CLO Manager, LLC, Bain Capital Credit (Asia) Limited, and BCSF Advisors, LP are collectively referred to as “Bain Capital Credit”, which are credit affiliates of Bain Capital, LP. Bain Capital Credit, LP, Bain Capital Credit CLO Advisors, LP, Bain Capital Credit U.S. CLO Manager, LLC, Bain Capital Credit U.S. CLO Manager II, LP, and BCSF Advisors, LP are investment advisers registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”). Registration with the Commission does not constitute an endorsement by the Commission nor does it imply a certain level of skill or training. Bain Capital Credit (Australia), Pty. Ltd. is regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”). Bain Capital Credit, Ltd. and Bain Capital Investments (Europe) Limited are authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) in the United Kingdom. Bain Capital Investments (Ireland) Limited is authorized by the Central Bank of Ireland. Bain Capital Credit (Asia) Limited and Bain Capital Private Equity (Asia) Limited are regulated by the Securities and Futures Commission in Hong Kong and are licensed to carry on Type 1 regulated activities under the Securities and Futures Ordinance. No securities commission or regulatory authority in the United States or in any other country has in any way passed upon the merits of an investment in a Bain Capital Credit investment vehicle or the accuracy or adequacy of the information or material contained herein or otherwise.
This written material provides a general introduction to Bain Capital Credit and its business and is intended for your sole use. It should not be relied upon as the basis for making any investment decision, entering into any transaction or for any other purpose.
Bain Capital Credit, its subsidiaries and affiliates and its and their respective employees, officers and agents make no representations as to the completeness and accuracy of any information contained within this written material. Information contained in this material is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as an offer or solicitation of any security or investment product, nor should it be interpreted to contain a recommendation for the sale or purchase of any security or investment product and is considered incomplete without the accompanying oral presentation and commentary.
Bain Capital Credit and its affiliates act for the funds and investment vehicles which they manage or advise (the “Vehicles”) and will not be acting for anyone else. In particular, Bain Capital Credit will not advise potential investors on subscriptions in any Vehicle or co-investments and will not arrange transactions on behalf of anyone other than the Vehicles or provide advice on the merits of such transactions. No representative of Bain Capital Credit has the authority to represent otherwise. Bain Capital Credit is not responsible for providing you with the protections afforded to its clients and you are strongly advised to take your own legal, investment and tax advice from suitably qualified advisers.
An investment in the Vehicles is speculative and involves a high degree of risk, which may not be suitable for all investors. The Vehicles may often engage in leveraging and other speculative investment practices that may increase the risk of investment loss and the investments may be highly illiquid. The Vehicles are not required to provide periodic pricing or valuation information to investors. Investing in the Vehicles may involve complex tax structures, and there may be delays in distributing important tax information. Private funds are not subject to the same regulatory requirements as mutual funds, and private fund advisers and sponsors often charge high fees. An investment in the Vehicles involves a number of significant risks and other important factors relating to investments in limited partnerships generally, and relating to the structure and investment objectives of a given Vehicle in particular. Investors should consider risks associated with the following: illiquidity and restrictions on transfer; tax considerations; valuation risks, and impact of fees on returns. The foregoing list of risk factors does not purport to be a complete enumeration of the risks involved in an investment in the Vehicles. Prospective investors should reference the offering documents and consult with their own legal, tax and financial advisors before deciding to invest in the Vehicles. Refer to a particular Vehicle’s offering documents for additional details, risk factors and other important considerations, including registration requirements for certain jurisdictions.
This material contains proprietary and confidential information and analysis and may not be distributed or duplicated without the express written consent of Bain Capital Credit or its affiliates. Distribution to, or use by, any person or entity in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or use would be contrary to law or regulation, or which would subject Bain Capital Credit or its affiliates to any registration requirement within such jurisdiction or country, is prohibited. By accepting this presentation, the recipient agrees to keep it confidential and return it promptly upon request.
The opinions and information contained in this material are provided for informational purposes only and represent the current good-faith views of the contributor at the time of preparation. These views are subject to change without notice of any kind. Contact your Bain Capital Credit representative for further information.
Certain information contained herein are not purely historical in nature, but are “forward-looking statements,” which can be identified by the use of terms such as “may,” “will,” “should,” “expect,“ “anticipate,” “project,” “estimate,” “intend,” “continue,” or “believe” (or negatives thereof) or other variations thereof. These statements are based on certain assumptions and are intended to illustrate hypothetical results under those assumptions (not all of which are specified herein). Due to various risks and uncertainties, actual events or results may differ materially from those reflected or contemplated in such forward-looking statements. As a result, investors should not rely on such forward-looking statements.
Certain information contained in this presentation has been obtained from published and non-published sources and/or prepared by third-parties and in certain cases has not been updated through the date hereof. Such information has not been independently verified by Bain Capital Credit, and Bain Capital Credit does not assume responsibility for the accuracy of such information (or updating the presentation based on facts learned following its issuance). All information contained herein is subject to revision and the information set forth herein does not purport to be complete.
This material has been provided to you solely for your information and may not be copied, reproduced, further distributed to any other person or published, in whole or in part for any purpose without the express written consent of Bain Capital or affiliates. Any other person receiving this material should not rely upon its content.
The Bain Capital square symbol is a trademark of Bain Capital, LP.
Discussion of Returns
Notes Regarding Pro Forma Investment Returns
Notes Regarding Pro Forma Bain Capital Special Situations Investment Returns
Investments described in these pro forma returns were held in various Bain Capital investment vehicles which may have applied different economic terms.
1 Represents Bain Capital’s view as of the date of this presentation and is subject to change
2 EIOPA 2020 European Insurance Overview, Feb. 28, 2022
3 Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35, Article 169. Type 1 (common equity) has a risk charge of 39% vs 49% for Type 2 (private equity)
4 “Investing in Europe: Private Equity Activity 2020”, Invest Europe, Jul. 7th, 2021. In 2020, Insurance companies made up 10% of new PE commitments vs 29% for Pension funds
5 European insurance AuM was estimated to be € 10,627 Bn as of Dec. 2020 Source: “European Insurance in Figures 2020” Insurance Europe. European pension assets are estimated to be € 4,604 Bn Source: “Pension Fund Statistics and Trends”, Pensions Europe as of March 2020
6 Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35, Article 168 (4)
7 Calculated as PE Allocation = [ Capital invested in Type 2 funds/ ( Capital invested in Type 2 funds + capital invested into public Type 1 equity)] Type 2 equity is defined as all other types of equity or commodities including private equity, EU Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35, Article 168 ¶3
8 Based on quarterly returns from Q1 2015 to Q2 2022. Sources: Bain Capital Credit Global Special Situations Track record (Net), Cambridge Associates Preliminary Net Returns for North American, European and Asian Buy-Out funds and MSCI World for global equities.. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Actual results may vary. Please see Endnotes for information on performance calculation methodologies and other important additional information.
9 Calculated as Sharpe Ratio = [ Mean LTM Return – (1+3M US Libor Rate)^.25-1)]/[ STD (Mean LTM Return – (1+3M US Libor Rate)^.25-1)]. Based on quarterly returns from Q1 2015 to Q2 2022. So Sources: Bain Capital Credit Global Special Situations Track record (Net), Cambridge Associates Preliminary Net Returns for North American, European and Asian Buy-Out funds and MSCI World for global equities.. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Actual results may vary. Please see Endnotes for information on performance calculation methodologies and other important additional information.